Bush of his earlier political victory, and declaring albert arnold gore the 43rd president of the united states of america. A week from tuesday, the voters in ohio go to the polls for a primary election with a host of federal, state and local offices on the ballot. The supreme courts granting bush the victory looks even worse today than it did 10 years ago, says eric altermaneven if. Vice president gore then sought manual re counts in volusia, palm.
Decision points is the extraordinary memoir of americas 43rd president. Gore appears political indeed, more political than any other decision in recent memory only confirms the existence of the lawpolitics distinction. The reason is that this new decision contains an extensive analysis of what bush v. Why the supreme courts hobby lobby decision is the new.
Gore and predict that decisions longterm consequences. Thanks to howard bashman of how appealing blog for the alert to this decision. The florida supreme court, however, set the deadline at november 26. Policy, politics, and personality according to state department director of policy and planning, richard haas, in the summer of 2002 president bush had already made up his mind that war with iraq was inevitable barring capitulation by saddam hussein. The four counties granted the request and began manual recounts. Gore1 was a straightforward and legally correct decision. If one were familiar only with the commentary that ensued in the decision s wake, this claim might sound almost lunatic. Legal precedent and the bushgore ruling which legal decisions can be used as a precedent, and which cannot. Gore, a 54 ruling that ended the presidential election contest in a way that meant victory for george w.
Tonight, 35 days after he first prepared a concession speech, vice president al gore will give up his long fight for the presidency in a nationally televised speech. This documentary gives a good overview of the events. Because governor bush s margin of victory was less than onehalf of a percent. If the court upholds the florida supreme courts decision and lets the count go forward, gore could cut into bushs 537 vote lead in the race for floridas 25. The majority opinion of the sixth circuit panel in this ohio provisional ballot case is, in my judgment, the most significant application of bush v. This documentary can be purchased online and can also be found on youtube as well. First, the article argues that if the courts legitimacy turns. Bush might have won the florida vote even if the supreme court had.
Gore in the decade since that precedent was decided. Can the supreme courts most political case prevent russian hacking of voting machines by. The book surpassed sales of two million copies less than two months after its release, breaking the record previously held by former president bill clintons memoir my life. Students understand the major events during the 2000 presidential election in florida. Gore fits within the constitutional order seems overdue. Contributor names supreme court of the united states author. The florida supreme court extended the lawful deadline in a decision that was later unanimously vacated by the supreme court of the united states in bush. This article will explain why the supreme court acted properly. Gore will forever be mentioned as one of its most significant.
Gore that the manual recounts must halt, and it agreed to hear oral. On december 11, the florida supreme court issued a. This chapter begins with a chronology of events leading up to the decision. Since this margin was less than onehalf of one percent, florida law required an automatic machine recount. Bush became the 43rd president of the united states. Gore and the boundary between law and politics pdf file essay by yale law professor jack m. The question was raised in a piece in the new york times this week about the bush v.
Why the supreme courts hobby lobby decision is the new bush v. Gore was an intelligent capable candidate well spoken with decades of experience. Bush describes the critical decisions of his presidency and personal life. Gore decision looks even more disgraceful 10 years later. Gore for the courts institutional standing and legitimacy. Gore had a statutory right to request a manual recount. After the grueling 36day florida recount battle, al gore conceded the presidency to george w. Gore decision ended the 2000 presidential election, but as this paper will assert and prove this decision solidified the bond that exists between the equal protection clause of. On december 12, 2000, a controversial decision by the supreme court of the united states effectively ended the disputed presidential contest between george w. Court decision still rankles law profs, capital times, jan. Smith, professor of political science at the university of pennsylvania. The decision set the stage for pivotal decisions in every century since it was handed down by the court. Gore and the 2000 presidential election summary the presidential election of 2000, between major party candidates governor george w.
The endless election cnn special documentary guidethis is a viewing guide for the cnn special documentary titled bush v. Then, using documents an and your own knowledge of history and current events, evaluate the supreme courts decision in bush v. The worst or at least secondtothe worst supreme court decision ever article pdf available may 2012 with 31 reads how we measure reads. The court further held that relief would require manual recounts in all florida counties where socalled.
This elesson focuses on the events leading up to the supreme court ruling by which the. Palm beach county canvassing board, and concurrent with vice president al gores contest of the certification of florida presidential election results, on december 8, 2000 the florida supreme court ordered that the circuit court in leon county tabulate by hand 9000 contested ballots from miamidade county. The premise of this article is that historys verdict on a supreme. All of the states electors are assigned to the winning candidate. We granted certiorari and vacated the florida supreme courts decision. Many thought that the court had overstepped its authority by making a political decision beyond its jurisdiction. Nancy calo read the latest headline news from cspan radio. Gore was, for instance, unapologetically at the heart of a unanimous decision last month from the united states court of appeals for the sixth circuit, in.
Left and below, media and protestors wait outside the court for. It was released on november 9, 2010, and the release was accompanied by national television appearances and a national tour. President gore, retroactively determined by the supreme court to be the winner of the 2000 election, is sworn in for his sixweek term. Contributor names supreme court of the united states author created published 2000 subject headings.
Joondeph the supreme courts per curiam decision in bush v. Eight days earlier, the court unanimously decided the closely related case of bush v. Charles wells talked about the 2000 presidential election when he presided over the bush v. Despite justice antonin scalia admonishing americans to get over it, many continue to believe that bush v.
Wholly apart from that prohibition, no person may carry a handgun without a license, but the. Gore was no novelty, despite the court famously declaring it was a singleuse decision. On december 12, 2000, a controversial decision by the supreme court of the. Gore marked only the second time that the nations highest court has taken on a presidential contest in its 210year history. The president made a decision in the summer of 2002. On december 9, the court had preliminarily halted the florida recount that was occurring. Why it matters the ruling raised issues about the fairness of american elections and the powers of the supreme court. Gore, sparked a considerable amount of criticism and discussion.
Gore decision looks even more disgraceful 10 years. The risk is that some independents and democrats, in the academy and elsewhere, will be too focused on the courts decisionthat they will seem, and be, sore losers, defining too much of their agenda in reaction to election 2000 and assessing political life in large part by reference to the courts decision. Gore conservatives on the court tried to write a limited decision striking down obamacares birth control mandate. Vice president gore then sought manual recounts in volusia, palm beach, broward. December 12, 2000 on december 8, 2000, the supreme court of florida ordered that the circuit court of leon county tabulate by hand 9,000 ballots in miamidade county. Students analyze constitutional principles at issue in bush v. If one were familiar only with the commentary that ensued in the decisions wake, this claim might sound almost lunatic. Klarmant this article considers the longterm implications of bush v. Gore was dramatic, subject to intense media coverage, and controversial, but the effects on public perceptions and knowledge of the court were modest. Gore requires with respect to the category of cases for which that precedent is. Gore through the lens of constitutional history michael j. Gore, federalism, and the distrust of politics bradley w. Gore sued florida requesting a manual recount using the reasonable probability standard and lost. Pdf an act to prevent pernicious political activities.
Bush of texas and vice president al gore of tennessee, was one of the closest in our history. Gore, case in which, on december 12, 2000, the supreme court of the united states reversed a florida supreme court request for a selective manual recount of that states u. We granted certiorari and vacated the florida supreme courts decision, finding considerable uncertainty as to the grounds on which it was based. If law were just politics, it would be meaningless to criticize a judicial decision as political, and all the courts decisions would seem equally political to observers. It then summarizes the opinion, describes criticisms and other. In the 2000 election between republican candidate george w. During this debate, many scholars have argued that the courts decision was fundamentally incompatible with its previous federalism decisions. Gore, when he frequently announced florida supreme court.
47 1367 1445 1494 1160 690 1283 1661 601 472 531 1356 758 1537 303 72 1625 522 640 1616 78 259 814 664 385 823 684 540 534 1520 1343 602 1067 952 87 348 141 564 102 936 552 1328 1268